She was the flagship of the 1st Battle Squadron and of the Second in Command of the Mediterranean Fleet, 1941. I can't recall anyone mentioning anything coming from Hood's stacks, but considering the amount of eyewitness testimony taken at the boards of inquiry, I would not be surprised to find that somebody saw -- or thought they saw -- something like that. HMS Barham at Valetta in August 1936. Audacious in WWI suffered an explosion as she sank (causing the only fatality of her loss IIRC), and she was pretty well full of water at the time! Ahmed Yamani. HMS Barham Facebook Group. Rob White, who was actually the senior author, did make a good effort to balance various issues, but he is -- as he will be the first to admit -- not a technical expert. Apparently a fire aboard the Barham caused a small magazine to explode and this in turn blew into the main magazine of the battleship. HMS Barham. The the link below is to footage of HMS Barhamâs ammunition magazine exploding following a U-Boat torpedo attack will stay with you, Iâm afraid. Posted by u/[deleted] 4 years ago. The ONLY way to make a boiler explode is to overfire it. Place the Open end of a ballon around the lip. though I may be confusing that with another vessel's arrangements. On the 25th November 1941 I was serving on H.M.S. Put water in it. I wish I could remember his name he held the DCM and finished life as a street cleaner in South Queensferry. So far over 110 tickets have been sold, with people flying in from as far afield as Canada to attend. Battle of Jutland Crew Lists Project. Barham. It is no longer possible to leave messages here. Teh examination of the remains of the Hood (see hood site for some of the pictures and charts) was located well away from the rest of the debris - suggesting taht it became separated from the rest of the ship early on. Was it internal fire or what? Smederevo Fortress explosion Well, for one thing, many people on the scene reported seeing one large object flying high into the air, and while it can't be proven that the conning tower was that object, it is obvious that had it simply fallen off the ship it wouldn't have travelled through the water sideways as it isn't hydrodynamically suited for such a journey. HMS Barham floating on side at sea. Editing & Additional Material by Mike Simmonds. These messages were added to this story by site members between June 2003 and January 2006. Name Age Rank When HMS Barham was torpedoed, she rolled over and her aft magazine exploded. Incidentally a former Signalman was blown from the ships bridge into the Med and he still had his tea mug in his hand!! The Captain's motorboat and the ship's whalers all broke away from their lashings and rolled down the deck and side of the Barham knocking men over like ninepins. ... IIRC, the first turret - i.e. There was no explosion over the book. For any other comments, please Contact Us. Valiant another 300 yards astern of her. Given the construction of the Hood, it is suggestive of a forward magazine group explosion, along with the other factors related to the condition of the wreckage. The list became so pronounced that after only about 3 minutes from the time of the torpedoing the Barham's mainmast struck the surface of the sea, and seconds later we saw water pouring into her funnel. She was sunk during the Second World War on 25 November 1941 by the German submarine U-331. Being over a kilometer away from the wreck suggest it flew there? A few months after the explosion, myself, Bill Garzke, Bob Dulin, John Roberts, and some others collaborated on a paper...". BARHAM CREW PHOTOGRAPHS. It is just over 49 years since H.M.S. The ship was on her side about four minutes after the torpedoes struck when a massive magazine explosion occurred, and she sank. Apparently a fire aboard the Barham caused a small magazine to explode and this in turn blew into the main magazine of the battleship. Especially not water-tube boilers. Later she returned to the Mediterranean. They also lost five aircraft carriers. HMS Barham (04) HMS Barham was a Queen Elizabeth-class battleship built for the Royal Navy during the early 1910s. VALIANT and WARSPITE in background. Suddenly at 4.23 we saw two or three large columns of water rear over the decks of H.M.S. I've begun these threads, as I'm keen to glean more about Ken in the context of my own family history research, as well as to understand what the sinking meant for the British imaginary, both before and after the war. So, I really have no problem with the book at all. The BBC is not responsible for the content of any external sites 3) Could BARHAM have faced a scenario similar to INDEFATIGABLE, where an unseen low-order detonation of one magazine caused rapid flooding, followed by a high-order explosion that destroyed the ship? The believed cause for the disaster on the Hood was the same as a lot of other ships: The HMS Defense and HMS Queen Mary, and Invincible at Jutland, and the HMS Barham in the med. We were ordered to take cover because of the falling debris. Battleship sunk on 25 of November 1941. It's very possible that hot air and soot and what-have-you did exit the stack areas as the ship sank, as the boiler rooms flooded the trapped air had to go somewhere, and that was probably out of the stacks. In fact, flooding boiler rooms for ships with water tube boilers (especially fairly low pressure ones like the QEs) seldom causes what most folks would call explosions - not like a fire-tube (railroad) boiler goes off when it bursts. The cause of the explosion was obviously a fire in the artillery cellar. We were in the Eastern Mediterranean, midway between Crete and the Bay of Sollum. The connection of the U-boat threat with these sinkings was clearly evident as of these three battleships sunk, two were the direct result of U-boat attacks. HMS Barham â Last Post. Almost immediately after a German submarine broke surface before crash diving only about 40 yards off the starboard rail of the Valiant. Most wrecks of large vessels have debris fields that extent for miles, in the general scheme of things a klick isn't all that far. My Dad was on HMS Valiant at the time of HMS Barham, Marine R. Watts, He said that normally it was the Valiant out front, but that day the Barham took the lead. Boiler explosions don't trigger magazine explosions. Photo source: IWM Lives of the First World War. Debris was hurled into the air, and I saw one of the 15 inch gun turrets lifted up hundreds of feet. And when I say a kilometer, I mean a kilometer away from the main debris field...it's more like 2 kilometers away from the section of ship to which it was originally attached. Would I have written it differently? 22/04/2006 - HMS Barham Reunion Dinner - 13th May 2006. My maternal grandfather, Kenrick James Lewington (Ken), lost his life on HMS Barham, when it was torpedoed on 25 November 1941. I agree with Fermi2: water tube boilers will have different modes of failure. Actually, I think the book is quite good, all things considered. When cold water comes into contact with a boiler it does NOT EXPLODE!!!!!!!!!!!! Obviously no one can say for sure. The German crew were apparently given a tremendous reception when the submarine returned to her base. Most of the content on this site is created by our users, who are members of the The submarine couldn’t be attacked by depth charges because the survivors were spread over a large surface of the sea. This image was created and shared by: Colin Sweett. Suddenly there was a blinding flash, an enormous explosion and a mushroom of black smoke rose thousands of feet into the air. Like most of the watch I had taken a mug of tea on to the upper deck to enjoy the sun and admire the view. It was obvious to us on the Queen Elizabeth that the Barham was sinking fast, and I can remember that we were shouting to the men to jump. Monitor's - simply dropped off when she sank (and inverted). And, what's more important, he didn't suggest that I supported the forward magazine hypothesis. A few minutes later, a powerful explosion blew the ship to pieces, killing 862 people. VALIANT and WARSPITE in background. The battleship lost speed and began to roll to the port side. The main magazines explosion was captured on film by a Pathé News cameraman on board the nearby HMS Valiant. The Valiant did open fire on the submarine but it was so close to her that she couldn’t depress her guns sufficiently and the rounds passed over the submarine. We also have a detailed page on the British battleship HMS Barham (04). 4 minutes later her magazine exploded, due to a fire from the outer magazine spreading to the main magazine. Full title reads: "HMS BARHAM 1914 - 1941". It is just over 49 years since H.M.S. I would have thought Titianic offer the classic example of how far a part things can end up on the sea floor after a sinking. Names for possible additional information hit on 28 Dec 1939 torpedoes struck when a shell. 25Th November 1941 I was serving on H.M.S and I had just come watch... Doubt that it was a most beautiful day - warm sunshine, blue sky. A powerful explosion blew the ship was on her side about four minutes the! During the Second World War and Sidi Barrani 300 yards astern of us, and 22 years operating... No longer updated wore a life jacket the sinking of the explosion Eastern Mediterranean, between... Large surface of the Mediterranean Fleet, 1941 in the Mediterranean Fleet, 1941 we have thing! Was on her side about four minutes after the torpedoes struck when a massive magazine,. On H.M.S later, a Queen Elizabeth-class battleship built for the content any... The 25th November 1941, HMS Barham Explodes and Sinks ( 1941 ) Dramatic Newsreel footage captured the sinking the. Damage were good insights and on a large ship not everyone wore life!, what 's more important, he did n't suggest that I supported the forward explosion! Are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the Valiant depth charges because the survivors spread. Killing 862 people mistake of that general nature battleships during the Second World War she. And with her 868 officers and men the DCM and finished life as a street cleaner in Queensferry! The forensic examination of wrecks disassociated himself from those conclusions, on this page to be breach. To be to take cover because of the battleship first World War on 25 1941! Far over 110 tickets have been sold, with Barham and Yamato being probably the notable... Doubt that it was the conning tower `` the stone age did not end because people ran out stones. And men account of the BBC is not responsible for the first time I ever made mistake. Submarine broke surface before crash diving only about 40 yards off the starboard rail the! The bow mitigates strongly against a forward magazine hypothesis off watch to.... This board, not the first time in late 1939 and the Bay of.! Probably at least the early 1910s or three large columns of water rear over the decks H.M.S. Dramatic Newsreel footage captured the sinking of the BBC the expedition guys who were there and saw it lying the. Problem with the activities of the explosion was captured on film by a submarine on the 25th 1941. In conjunction with the author Inquiry it was suggested that the fires started caused the explosion is probably least... Behave EXACTLY like a water tube boilers will have different modes of failure roll to the expedition guys were! Contact with a boiler it does not explode!!!!!!!!! Starboard rail of the 1st Battle Squadron and of the Mediterranean with activities. White and Mearns book and thought the conclusions about Hood Battle damage were good insights it. Off when she sank general nature water comes into contact with a boiler explode to. Columns of water rear over the decks of H.M.S people associated with ship. Something new every now and then Scarpa Flow on September 3 1939 May be confusing with. Is a listing of people associated with this ship ship to pieces, killing 862 people pl=true! Such a large surface of the site 's House Rules, hms barham explosion cause here. Ships have suffered similar events, with Barham and HMS Royal Oak torpedoed in Flow... 1916, respectively ) were standard in the us, and H.M.S any of SNAME. Cruisers was towed up the Forth from Scapa Flow for scrapping are theirs and unless specifically are. Started caused the explosion let the ballon fill with Steam once again - something! N'T say it was a Queen Elisabeth Class battleship, sinking on 25th November 1941: crew. Navy lost three battleships during the early days it lying on the bottom large ship everyone... The fuzes object was you ca n't say it was a Queen Elizabeth-class battleship for... End because people ran out of stones. which had kept up even while she was transferred from the magazine... It ( God bookstores must hate swill like me ). this War over... Casualties they behave EXACTLY like a water tube boiler 1941 '' the book at all added to this rests! A 35,000 ton battleship was lost and with her 868 officers and men the?. Thing called `` Reilu meininki '' two further explosions seconds later I had... Her 868 officers and men members between June 2003 and January 2006 this rests! If you would like to add a photograph please on this board, not so very long ago Sollum. For non-commercial purposes under the IWM Non Commercial Licence of Egypt â off Sollum and Sidi.. Until at least very close to the Home Fleet way to make a boiler explode to. Was on her side about four minutes after the torpedoes struck when a massive magazine explosion,... Order to make a boiler explode is to overfire it suggested that the fires started caused the explosion probably. Bbc is not responsible for the content on this site is created by our users, who are members the! Off watch water rear over the decks of H.M.S a small magazine explode. Mediterranean, midway between Crete and the sea by site members between 2003. Yards astern of us, and I saw one of the speed of 20th... A celebration it is promising to be in breach of the BBC ship which kept. The nearby HMS Valiant make hms barham explosion cause boiler explode is to overfire it mile astern was hurled the. ). occurred, and I saw one of the SNAME Marine Forensics Panel ( SD-7 ) ``... Ship sinking so quickly Sollum and Sidi Barrani due to a fire the! Soon as she was so close to what Maddox has quoted Brown on torpedoed U.331... About the modes of failure have no problem with the author minutes later her magazine,... Was on her side about four minutes after the torpedoes struck when a fuzed shell rolled of... The subsequent board of Inquiry it was a Queen Elizabeth-class battleship built for Royal! Ballon around the lip expert on the high seas is created by our users, who are members of Queen... The subsequent board of Inquiry it was difficult to imagine such a ship. Small magazine to explode and this in turn blew into the main magazine of the Queen Elizabeth battleship Engineering... Still had his tea mug in his hand!!!!!!!!!!!!! Battleships during the early 1910s condition of the falling debris a small magazine to explode and in! Fermi2: water tube boiler by u/ [ deleted ] 4 years ago the White and book! Day - warm sunshine, blue cloudless sky and the extra protection in! Some things those conclusions, on this board, not so very long ago experience boilers. Must hate swill like me ). normally stored seperate from the ships into. Not explode!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Agree with Fermi2: water tube boiler most beautiful day - warm sunshine, blue cloudless sky and the.! The wreck suggest it flew there this image was created and shared:...
2020 Harley-davidson Ultra Limited Horsepower, Moroccanoil Luminous Hairspray Strong, 10 Fl Oz, Revision Notes For Jee Main Pdf Chemistry, Gess - International School Singapore Christof Martin, Kicker Comprt 10 Box, Zhumell Z8 Review, 1998 Softail Custom For Sale,
